top of page

Crafting Flies for Ontario Northern Pike: A Guide to Durable and Effective Designs

Writer's picture: Matt MartinMatt Martin

When it comes to targeting Ontario’s Northern Pike on the fly, few experiences are as exhilarating. These apex predators are aggressive, powerful, and forgiving when it comes to a well-presented fly. For fly anglers, the key to success often lies in the flies themselves—bold, flashy, and durable designs that can withstand sharp teeth and relentless strikes. Whether you're chasing pike in the weed beds of your local lake or exploring the pristine waters with Smooth River Guiding (our spring trips are filling fast—don’t miss out!), this guide will help you tie flies that deliver results.


Let’s break down the three essential pike fly patterns I rely on: the Polar Changer, Deceiver-style flies, and the Yard Sale. We’ll cover how to tie them for maximum durability and appeal, using the right materials and techniques.


The Polar Changer: Versatility and Movement

Designed by Blaine Chocklett, the Polar Changer is a masterclass in blending natural movement with synthetic durability. Built on articulated shanks, this multi-segmented fly mimics baitfish with lifelike undulation. The key material here is Chocklett's Filler Flash, a synthetic that combines translucence with irresistible sparkle. For Ontario pike, consider tying Polar Changers in white, chartreuse, or black and red—colors that trigger aggressive strikes.


Tips for Durability:

Thread: Use GSP (gel-spun polyethylene) thread. Its strength ensures your materials stay locked in, even after repeated abuse.

Glue: Secure each segment with a dab of Zap-A-Gap. Apply glue at every tie-in point to ensure nothing shifts during casting or after a strike.

Materials: Combine Filler Flash with polar fibre brushes, or spin your own dubbing loops. Progressively increase the size of your loops as you move from the back shank, to the single 3/0 hook at the head. This ensures the fly maintains a natural taper and swims without excess drag in the water.


Deceiver-Style Flies: The Classic That Never Fails

The Deceiver, originally crafted by Lefty Kreh, is a timeless fly for targeting predatory fish. For pike, upsize the design—think 5 to 8 inches long—to match their preference for larger prey. These flies are perfect for open water or when targeting fish holding near structure.


Materials:

Bucktail: A durable and versatile natural material, bucktail forms the body and tail of the fly. Its natural taper and movement make it a pike angler's staple.

Schlappen Feathers: Use these for tails to add pulsating motion in the water.

Flash: Incorporate Flashabou or Polar Flash sparingly to create an attention-grabbing shimmer.

Construction Tips:

Start with a long-shanked hook or add an articulated shank for extra length.

Tie in some bucktail for the tail, before adding tail feathers. This helps reduce the chance of the feathers fouling on the hook. Alternating colors for contrast in the bucktail wing is important (e.g., white under olive, or red under black).


Finish the fly with a durable epoxy head or a dab of Zap-A-Gap to lock everything in place.

The Deceiver’s simplicity and effectiveness make it a must-have in any pike angler’s box.


The Yard Sale: Flashy and Effective Chaos

Designed by Matt Grajewski, the Yard Sale is all about creating maximum flash, profile and an irresistible side to side movement to draw pike from a distance. This fly lives up to its name, featuring a mishmash of materials that create a chaotic, yet irresistible, presentation. For Ontario waters, tie it in loud colors like chartreuse and orange or subtle combinations like black and purple.


Key Components:

Flash Materials: Use 4-6 Webby neck hackles for the tail, add Flashabou, or Polar Flash as well. Then stack flash n’ slinky as the body, this mimics the reflective qualities of baitfish scales as well as the right profile and ensures incredible movement on the retrieve.

Synthetic Fibers: synthetic materials like EP fibers, flash n’ slinky or Congo Hair make for a durable and water-shedding body.

Durability Enhancements:

Tie in small bunches of material at a time, securing each with GSP thread and a drop of Zap-A-Gap.

Build the fly on a heavy-duty hook or articulated platform to stand up to pike’s sharp teeth.


The Yard Sale might look chaotic, but its bold design is highly effective at triggering strikes, especially in stained water.


Choosing the Right Materials

Durability is critical when tying pike flies. Northern Pike are notorious for shredding poorly constructed patterns. By selecting the right materials and using proper techniques, you can ensure your flies last for multiple fish—and maybe even multiple trips.


Durable Natural Materials:

Bucktail: The workhorse of pike flies, it’s tough, sheds water well, and provides natural movement.

Schlappen Feathers: Great for creating lifelike undulation and bulk without adding too much weight.


Synthetic Options:

Chocklett’s Filler Flash: Adds body and flash without excessive bulk.

Flashabou and Polar Flash: Excellent for creating reflective highlights that mimic the scales of baitfish.

Synthetic Fibers: Durable and water-shedding, making them ideal for tying large profiles without adding unnecessary weight.

By combining natural and synthetic materials, you can achieve the perfect balance of movement, flash, and durability.


Tools of the Trade: Drift Outfitters

When it comes to sourcing materials for pike flies, Drift Outfitters in Toronto is a treasure trove. Located in the heart of the city, they stock everything you need—from premium bucktail to an array of synthetic materials. Whether you're a seasoned tyer or just starting out, their knowledgeable staff can guide you in selecting the best materials for your next creation. Matt from Smooth River Guiding will be hosting an intermediate fly tying lesson at the shop on February 5th, 2025 Check them out at www.driftoutfitters.com to sign up, or stock up before your next tying session.


Ready for Pike Season?

Ontario’s pike fishing season is just around the corner, and the time to prepare is now. Tying durable, effective flies will not only improve your chances of landing these aggressive predators but also enhance your experience on the water. If you're looking for an unforgettable adventure, Smooth River Guiding still has spring pike trips available—but spots are selling quickly. Visit www.smoothriver.ca to book your trip today!


Tight lines, and happy tying!


Matt Martin

54 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Spring Pike on the Fly in Central Ontario

Spring Pike on the Fly in Central Ontario By Matt Martin Spring marks the long-awaited start of pike season in Central Ontario, a time...

Comments


  • Instagram

©2022 by Smooth River Guiding Company.

bottom of page